Question:
Why play Electric Bass?
This Guy Knows Things
2010-07-17 15:32:48 UTC
Why do people choose to play bass? Thats like choosing to sit in a corner, be quiet and pretend like your doing something i mean you can hardly hear a bass over a guitar, drum, and singer so whats the point of having one i mean people hardly ever remember the names of bass players let alone pay any attention to them and bass players just sit in the back playing 4 to 8 notes over and over and over again. So why would someone want to play bass and not just play guitar? and why do people say bands need bassist?
Six answers:
jwhero
2010-07-17 16:38:52 UTC
Bass provides the general "feel" of a song. I think you'll find that songs would just sound "empty" if they only had a guitarist, a singer, and a drummer.



It is harder to shine as a bassist compared to a guitarist. But for me, they gain all the more respect if they do shine. I'll provide Chris from Muse and Flea from RHCP as an example here =)



And it depends on how lazy the person writing the music is. Sometimes the bass just echoes the root notes of the chords, which is epicly uncreative and results in the bassist playing 4 notes over and over again. But you can seriously get creative with bass if you want to, it's not limited to 8 notes per song.
2010-07-20 01:35:24 UTC
The whole purpose of playing music is not to show off how fast you can shred. Anybody can learn to do that if they put a few years of serious practice into it.



I believe the reason why you think the bassist is meant to play the same notes over and over is because you have never heard a great bassist. Have you never heard of Geddy Lee? Victor Wooten? Jaco Pastorius? The list goes on...



If you remove the bass from the majority of songs they will sound dull and lifeless. There's nothing connecting the drums to the guitars and it just sounds like a wall of high pitched noise.



Here's an example of what a bass can do to a song. If you don't like death metal, skip to the clean section at 4:00 and try to imagine how boring the song would be without the bassist.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NC6eOfQvHXM
Gabby! ;) tm
2010-07-17 15:43:26 UTC
Well... The bass is the base of the song sort of. Just look at Paul McCartney, bassist for the beatles, probably the most successful band of all time He was the second most famous beatle, next to John lennon (in my opinion). And there are more than just 4 to 8 notes! Plus its easy to find guitarists. Bassist, not so much. Bassist are awesome!
2010-07-18 00:11:27 UTC
Well you've certainly shown yer utter lack of knowledge & ignorance for musical composition & roles of instruments in bands.



The other answers did fine, tell me other than acoustic music what bands don't use bassists?

The white stripes, arguably but Jack has used his guitar with pedals to cover the bass sections & looping it.

The Doors arguably except Ray played the bass on Keyboard.



Hmm other than that i'm hard pushed to think of any others, i'm also hard pushed to think of any proper musicians that view the bass as a wasted piece of time to learn & think its the same as guitar
2016-03-05 20:33:11 UTC
It's not ackward, as long as you can reach all of the frets, you can play the bass. There are many female bassists out there. Go out and play what you want to play! I don't think there are any limitations for instruments that certain genders just 'can't' play. Good Luck!
baxterville
2010-07-17 17:51:35 UTC
If you listen to a band whose bassist is absent, you'll realize the importance of bass to the rhythm section. Bass provides an essential bridge between the drums and the melody. Most people don't realize how important it is until it's gone, and even then they can't quite put a finger on what's missing. They just know something is horribly wrong.



Bass isn't a glamour instrument, but there are lots of musicians who aren't making music to call attention to themselves. Orchestral players, for instance, are passionate about being part of the overall sound. Each of them is vital to the music, even though it's unlikely any of them will be singled out for adulation. It's much like that with bassists. Being part of the rhythm section, a bassist locks into a groove with the drummer and certainly isn't limited to four to eight notes. He/she supports the drummer and adds depth to the song that can't be achieved by trebly guitars.



A lot of guitarists assume they can play bass because they treat bass as though it were a four-stringed guitar. But the term "bass guitar" is entirely false, since the bass isn't a guitar at all. The only similarity is that electric basses are visually similar. But they're just portable, more easily amplified versions of the stand-up basses that have been a staple of music for a century. When people played stand-up basses, nobody regarded them as failed guitarists because audiences realized bass was an instrument in its own right. But since the advent of the electric instrument age, people have lost that understanding and confused bass and guitar. Most guitarists don't even know the difference, which is why guitarists tend to make horrible bassists. Since they're accustomed to playing guitar, they overplay -- cramming as many notes as possible into every song. They have no idea that doing so just makes everything sound muddy and chaotic, since they're so accustomed to showing off that they've never familiarized themselves with the role of the rhythm section. In contrast, bassists who switch to guitar tend to make great guitarists because they don't try to minimize the significance of the rhythm section.



Another advantage to being a bassist is that you can always find a band in need of your services. Way too many people approach music with the sole motive of being the center of attention. As a result, there are billions of great guitarists competing for a comparably small number of jobs. Every time I've run an ad seeking a guitarist, I've gotten hundreds of calls from mostly arrogant people who invite me to ride their coattails to fame and fortune. But when one of my bands runs an ad for a bassist, we're lucky if we receive a half dozen responses, since bassists are few and far between and very much in demand. A mediocre bassist can find work with a fantastic band, but a brilliant guitarist has to compete for work with hundreds of other great guitarists, most of whom think they're God's gift to music.


This content was originally posted on Y! Answers, a Q&A website that shut down in 2021.
Loading...