Hi Adam
Some people are asleep at the wheel sometimes. Both are good guitar but to say that Martin is garbage shows the knowledge of some of these guitar players. NONE.
Martin guitars come with a limited lifetime warranty and YES, they will respect it even if you have a crack 10 years down the line. Now that is what I call Warranty.
Also, Martin is the only guitar that do not use a Truss rod because they knwo they necks are straight and will stay straight. So no fiddling with any truss rod or fret adjustment.
Lastly, your money is guaranteed when you buy on line. Just pay with Paypal or a credit card and if not satisfied, your money is safe and secure.
You might want to check Canadian guitars made by Godin and Larivee. Because Canada have their own lumber yards, the quality of the wood and the manufactured guitar are top notch. Also, with your exchange, you can get a 30% discount and also, yiou can wheel and deal with canadian stores or manufactures.
Here are the links if interested and well worth looking at these 2 guitars. They are sold and reputable worldwide.
http://www.godinguitars.com/
http://www.larrivee.com/2_Main/main.html
These 2 guitars are hand-crafted to perfection with a darn good warranty.